$2 / month

Comment and reply across TML.

Start or manage membership

Most pulsed

Latest from other desks

tml.the modern leap
Life / Relationships

Flatmate Breaks Perfume Bottle, Fights Over The Leftovers

She apologized, she offered to replace it in full, and then she asked for the half that survived. That's where the agreement ended.

TML Life DeskNov 22, 3:50 AM ET · 2 min read
A designer perfume bottle (archive). Photo: Cpalaci1 / CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Summary

The replacement was never the argument. The argument is who owns what's left of the thing that broke.

Tap a passage. React to the part that matters.

A woman lent her flatmate her favorite perfume for a family event, and the bottle came back cracked with half of it gone.

The two women, both in their twenties, share a flat and get along well enough without being close, the poster wrote on r/AmItheAsshole. Her flatmate asked to borrow the good perfume for a family event, and she said yes.

The bottle slipped while the flatmate was putting it down. It cracked and spilled but didn't shatter, and she tilted what was left and dabbed at the spill with tissues until about half the perfume was still in the bottle, the poster wrote.

Then came the part nobody fought about: a full apology and an offer to replace the bottle outright, with no argument attached. The fight started with the follow-up question, when the flatmate asked whether she could keep what remained in the cracked bottle and decant it into one of her own.

The poster refused. "It's still my perfume," she wrote. "Just because she broke it and has to replace it doesn't entitle her to the perfume bottle that was mine from the start." She plans to decant the remainder for herself, she said, because the perfume was expensive.

Her flatmate's case is arithmetic. She's buying a whole new bottle, so the poster loses nothing, and the bottle broke by accident rather than through carelessness with something precious. She asked whether the perfume was a gift or carried sentimental value, and it wasn't either, though the poster calls it her favorite, the one she saves for special occasions.

Most of the commenters landed against the poster. A new bottle plus the surviving half leaves her with more perfume than she started with, they argued, and keeping both reads less like fairness and more like a fine. The thread turned into a small referendum on whether being made whole entitles you to the wreckage too.

The conversation

A little more perspective.

Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.

The conversation.

Loading comments…

Keep your curiosity going.

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we might make a commission — it never changes what you pay. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.