Poster Keeps Laptop Promise Despite Parents And Tears
A 24-year-old promised her working old laptop to a friend who couldn't afford one for college, and her parents decided her 16-year-old sister had the stronger claim.
The parents offered their own fix inside the argument: they could save up and buy the sister a laptop in a few months.
A poster on r/AmItheAsshole promised her old laptop to a broke college friend before her parents ordered it redirected to her teenage sister.
Her account, posted to Reddit and written up by TwistedSifter on November 10, lays out the sequence. She's 24, she bought a new laptop last month, and the old one still works perfectly. Her friend is a broke college student who needs a device for school, so she offered it for free, and they'd agreed she'd drop it off this weekend.
Then her parents found out. Her 16-year-old sister has been asking for a laptop for her online classes, and the parents said the machine should stay in the family and the friend could find another one. “I explained I already made a promise,” she wrote. Her sister cried and called it unfair that a stranger would get the laptop first, and her parents called her stubborn and selfish for refusing to tell her friend she'd changed her mind.
The detail that tilts the thread is one the parents supplied themselves. They told her they could save up and buy her sister a laptop in a few months, which gives the sister a delayed fix and the friend none at all. The friend has no spare money for a device, and the poster's whole position is that a promise with a date attached isn't hers to reassign.
Commenters quoted in the coverage mostly sided with keeping the promise, and the conflict was still unresolved when the post was written up. The machine is one laptop. The argument is about who gets to spend someone else's generosity, and on that question her parents and her friend are never going to agree.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.