Spending Intent Splits by Income: +18 Percent at the Top, -26 at the Bottom
Alvarez & Marsal's Fall 2026 Consumer Sentiment Survey — more than 2,000 U.S. adults, fielded in late August and early September — puts overall spending intent at +4 percent net, its highest since fall 2023. Total holiday intent is -14 percent net. The average is the least informative number in the release.
Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague
Overall spending intent reached +4 percent net, the highest since fall 2023. Holiday intent is -14 percent net — +18 among higher-income households, -26 among lower-income ones. There are two shoppers in this survey, moving in opposite directions.
Alvarez & Marsal's Consumer and Retail Group released its Fall 2026 Consumer Sentiment Survey on November 12, 2026, built from a nationally representative survey of more than 2,000 U.S. adults fielded in late August and early September. Overall spending intent reached +4 percent net — the share planning to spend more, minus the share planning to spend less — its highest level since fall 2023. The firm is plain about who carries the number: households earning above $100,000 account for nearly all of the momentum.
The two groups fund their intent differently, and the survey prints both mechanisms. Higher-income households' expectation of earning more jumped 10 points, to 63 percent, and their intent to spend more rose 7 points, to 25 percent. Lower-income households' earning expectations slipped 2 points, to 40 percent; their intent to save more fell 6 points, to 22 percent. Their spending intent rises because the saving falls. Alvarez & Marsal calls the result the widest savings gap between the groups since fall 2023 — 18 points — and managing director Chad Lusk summarized it as stronger earners turning earnings expectations into spending while everyone else gives up savings to keep up with essentials.
The holiday table makes the split concrete. Total holiday spending intent is -14 percent net, down from roughly -3 percent last fall. Higher-income households plan to spend more at +18 percent net, led by holiday meals and treats at +21 percent and travel at +17. Lower-income households plan to cut in every holiday category, at -26 percent net — shallowest on gifts for others, -16 percent, deepest on decorations, -43 percent, with travel at -36 and gifts for themselves at -34. A retailer reading only the +4 headline stocks for a recovery. A retailer reading the holiday table stocks for two different Christmases.
Where the money goes is just as uneven. Grocery leads the recovery, with net-more intent nearly doubling to +14 percent; lower-income households are net-negative in every category except grocery, at +7 percent, and pet supplies, flat. Health sits at the top of consumers' stated priorities. And a growing share of shoppers let software into the decision: 43 percent now let AI influence a final purchase at least sometimes, up from 35 percent in the spring — mostly, the firm says, to compare prices and value.
For businesses
Amazon Business is Amazon’s purchasing store for companies, with business accounts and quantity ordering.Register with Amazon BusinessFor a household setting its own holiday budget, the survey's useful distinction is the funding source. Spending backed by expected income can continue into January. Spending backed by saving less ends when the buffer does. The survey does not set anyone's ceiling; it shows which group is paying for the season out of earnings and which is paying out of the reserve.
Alvarez & Marsal runs this survey twice a year, so the spring edition will show whether the gap closed or hardened. For now the fall numbers describe a recovery with a dividing line through it, stated in the firm's own figures: confidence at the top, arithmetic at the bottom, and a holiday season that is +18 on one side of the $100,000 line and -26 on the other.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.