Households Are Trading Down at the Fastest Pace Since 2021
Bank of America Institute's spending tier composite — card spending across apparel, dining, grocery and travel, sorted against the median incomes of premium, standard and value stores — has trended down for years. Apparel and dining lead the shift; millennials lead the generations.
Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague
Bank of America Institute data shows households shifting spending toward value-tier merchants at the strongest pace since 2021. The spending continues. The tier drops.
Shoppers are not spending less. They are spending lower. A Bank of America Institute report finds consumers trading down — shifting purchases toward value-tier merchants instead of premium ones — at the strongest pace since 2021. The measure is the bank's spending tier composite: consumer spending data across four categories, apparel, dining, grocery and travel, read against the median incomes of shoppers at premium, standard and value stores. The composite has trended downward for the past few years, which in the bank's construction means more households' dollars landing at the value end.
The bank's economist draws the line the data supports. "Consumers are still spending, and they're adapting to inflation, but adapting is not the same thing as escaping it," Taylor Bowley of the Bank of America Institute told Business Insider. "They're still finding ways to stretch their budgets by trading down where they have those choices." Wage growth remains positive, Bowley said, which absorbs some of the price rise — "but that can only go so far, especially when it comes to things like maybe housing."
Where households trade down depends on where a cheaper substitute exists. The bank's data shows trading down most prevalent in apparel and dining, the two categories where substitution is easiest. Travel runs the other way in the metric, and the report supplies its own caveat: airline spending growth is robust largely because fares are higher while transactions dip; hotel spending has renewed strength; cruise spending is often a budget-friendly way to travel. The travel increase may record lower-budget travelers skipping trips altogether rather than anyone feeling less price-conscious.
The generational split is the specific part. Millennials are trading down, the bank says, under the arithmetic of early middle age: many are parents paying for childcare on top of housing costs and auto payments that have run higher for their generation. Gen Z has consistently scored lower on the composite than older generations, which the report attributes to lower incomes and fewer accumulated assets. Baby boomers hold the highest composite, and Bowley described their shopping habits as steady.
For businesses
Amazon Business is Amazon’s purchasing store for companies, with business accounts and quantity ordering.Register with Amazon BusinessA survey built on answers rather than card data lands in the same place. In the University of Michigan's latest consumer survey, about 57 percent of respondents spontaneously mentioned that high prices have eroded their living standards — the highest share since May, up from 46 percent in February. Earnings calls tell it from the other side of the register. Performance Food Group chief executive Scott McPherson said consumers remain value-conscious and selective, with gas around $4 a gallon adding pressure. Advance Auto Parts chief financial officer Ryan Grimsland said hard parts categories are still soft as value-conscious consumers defer big repair projects. Ollie's chief executive Eric van der Valk said higher-income customers are also trading down in search of value, while lower-income customers prioritize needs over wants.
The practical read is the bank's own distinction. Trading down is adaptation, not relief: the spending continues, the standard quietly drops, and it shows first in the categories where a family can choose a cheaper version without going without — clothes and restaurants. The composite says that choice is now being made more widely than at any point since 2021.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.