CFTC Event Contract Comment Window Closes Wednesday
Two Federal Register texts published the same October morning would write event contracts into the federal definition of a swap while carving casino-style gambling out of it. Comments on both close November 18, and only one of the two is already law.
Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague
Comments on both CFTC texts close November 18. The casino-style exclusion is already in force, and the event-contract inclusion is still a proposal.
A wager on Sunday's game and a hedge on the election sit in the same apps, and Washington decides Wednesday what to call them. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission has two documents open, a proposal that names event contracts as swaps and an interim rule that excludes casino-style gambling products from the swap definition, and the comment period on both ends November 18.
The two texts carry different legal weight, and the difference is the whole story for anyone holding a position. The proposal, published October 19, would add language to the swap definition at 17 CFR 1.3 stating that swaps include event contracts, expressly including contracts on sports, politics, culture, and weather. The interim final rule, published the same day, took effect immediately, and it excludes casino-style gambling products, including sportsbook wagers and casino games, from the definition.
The commission is unusually plain about the proposal's practical effect. It says it preliminarily believes the change would not alter market participants' rights or obligations, because the agency already treats event contracts as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act. Read as a ledger entry, the proposal writes down what the agency says it already does, while the interim rule removes a category of retail gambling from the swaps book entirely.
The friction sits in the states, where gaming regulators never agreed the contracts were swaps in the first place. KalshiEX, the largest event contract exchange, is litigating against state regulators in New York, Arizona, Michigan, Washington, and Nevada, and state cases in the Ninth and Sixth Circuits turn on whether a federally regulated swap can also be a state-regulated bet. The proposal's own footnotes show federal enforcement already running: a servicemember charged over trades on the ouster of Venezuela's president, a Google employee charged over trades on the company's Year in Search list, and former Congressman George Santos penalized over a State of the Union contract.
For businesses
Amazon Business is Amazon’s purchasing store for companies, with business accounts and quantity ordering.Register with Amazon BusinessFor anyone holding a contract tonight, the footnote that matters is the calendar. Nothing in either document changes an open position this week, and the exclusion rule is already in force while the inclusion rule remains a proposal until the commission votes a final text. Comments filed by November 18 become part of the record the agency has to answer, and the final rule, whenever it lands, is the document that sets what platforms owe their customers.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.