Dane County Declines To Charge Officer In Ruiz Shooting
Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne announced on November 19 that Madison officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson won't face criminal charges for the July 22 shooting that killed Corey Ruiz, and the family and the mayor rejected the decision within hours.
Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague
The criminal case is closed on the prosecutor's reading of the videos, and the department's own reviews now decide what the shooting changes.
Elsa Ruiz wiped tears at a Madison news conference on November 19 while the prosecutor's decision sat on the table in front of her. "This is so wrong. They have no idea what I have to live with every day, him not being here," she said. "It hurts so bad." Hours earlier, Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne had announced that no criminal charges would be filed against the officer who shot her son.
Ozanne's four-page statement walks through the July 22 encounter step by step, and it rests on three facts as he found them, because four officers tried to arrest Corey Ruiz, 38, after he fled from them. Ruiz resisted the arrest and produced a knife during the struggle, while two officers fired stun guns at him first. The stun guns didn't stop him, and officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson fired three times and struck Ruiz twice. Ozanne concluded the use of deadly force was reasonable under those facts.
Ozanne said, "I conclude it was reasonable for the officer to use deadly force when this person resisted officers, produced a knife, and was not affected by multiple attempts to use Tasers while officers attempted to take him into custody." He said he reached the decision after he reviewed police reports, diagrams, surveillance videos, squad car videos and citizen videos, while no charges will be filed against the other three officers either. The state Department of Justice released its investigative file the same day, and the file runs to nearly 1,800 pages.
Baitinger-Peterson told state investigators in a July 31 interview that he feared Ruiz would stab him and the other officers at close range, and the investigative file says he moved to his handgun because he believed deadly force was his only option. A toxicology report in Ozanne's statement showed methamphetamine and substances that indicate cocaine use in Ruiz's system, while Ozanne's statement doesn't say Baitinger-Peterson was cut by the knife. Earlier city accounts had told residents an officer was injured by it during the struggle.
The family's lawyer read the same videos and reached the opposite conclusion in front of a packed room at the Center for Black Excellence and Culture, because civil rights attorney Ben Crump said, "We believe the district attorney should've charged this officer for killing Corey Ruiz." He called the shooting "clearly an excessive use of force," and he said county medical staff told the family Ruiz would have survived if the second shot, the one that struck him in the head, hadn't been fired. Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway called the decision "disheartening" and said the four officers' continued employment made trust hard for the community to give.
The criminal question is closed, and two reviews now carry the case into next year under Madison Police Chief John Patterson's plan, because an outside expert will run an internal use-of-force review. An outside organization will run a sentinel review of the department's handling of the shooting, while the four officers stay on administrative leave during the internal review. Protesters gathered on November 19 at Williamson and South Baldwin streets, the intersection where Ruiz was shot, and marched to the Wisconsin State Capitol, while the shooting had already pushed the city council to fund body cameras for Madison officers in its 2027 budget. Only the city's Police and Fire Commission can fire an officer from the department.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.