$2 / month

Comment and reply across TML.

Start or manage membership

Most pulsed

Latest from other desks

tml.the modern leap
Money / Business

Report Says Nearly Three In Ten Amazon Deals Saved Nothing

Groundwork Collaborative priced 351 products from Amazon's own Black Friday and Cyber Monday deal pages in 2024 and 2025 and found 29.1 percent cost the same or more than the lowest price of the prior 30 days, a finding Amazon calls deeply flawed.

TML Markets DeskNov 18, 7:52 AM ET · 3 min read

Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague

Amazon's fulfillment center in Shakopee, Minnesota (archive). Photo: Tony Webster, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Summary

The two numbers a shopper can check before checkout are the item's 30-day low and the price on the deal page, and the disclosure fight is over whether the first one has to be printed next to the second.

Tap a passage. React to the part that matters.

The headline number splits into two piles once the report's own table is open. Of 351 products pulled from Amazon's own Black Friday and Cyber Monday deal pages in 2024 and 2025, 29.1 percent were priced the same or higher during the sale than the lowest price recorded in the 30 days before it, according to Groundwork Collaborative, a Washington think tank. Inside that pile, 9.4 percent cost more during the sale than a price available in the prior month, and more than half of the items had matched or beaten their sale price at some point in the 90 days before the event.

Groundwork took its prices from Keepa, a third-party tracker that records Amazon listing prices several times a day, and benchmarked each sale price against the item's lowest price over the prior 10, 30 and 90 days. The 30-day window carries the headline because a European Union consumer protection directive uses it as the reference standard. The sample came from the pages Amazon itself curates for the events, 185 items from the 2025 Black Friday page and 152 from Cyber Monday, plus smaller 2024 pages, and Amazon says the events offered more than 10 million deals in total. The 351 are a sample of the storefront window, and the dispute is over what that window proves.

Two listings carry the argument in dollars. An Apple Watch Series 10 listed on sale at $679.99 on Black Friday 2025 had been priced at $602 a few weeks earlier, a $77.99 gap in the wrong direction. A pair of men's UGG Butte boots listed at $179.98 on Cyber Monday 2025 had cost $98.40 in the prior month. Groundwork's proposed fix is a disclosure rule that would require Amazon and other retailers to state the lowest listed price from the 30 days before an advertised sale, next to the sale price, in place of a list price or typical price chosen by the seller.

"Americans are really squeezed right now, and they are waiting to do their holiday shopping at these major sales events because they believe that these major sales events offer real savings and a real deal," Lindsay Owens, Groundwork's president and chief executive, said in an interview. She said the report shows that waiting for Black Friday or Cyber Monday "may not be all it's cracked up to be." Groundwork spent a year on the study, Owens said, and the group says Amazon has not identified any specific inaccuracy among the items in the sample.

AdFour office chairs in a rowFor businessesAmazon Business is Amazon’s purchasing store for companies, with business accounts and quantity ordering.Register with Amazon Business

Amazon's answer arrived before the report did, in a November 13 letter to Owens and her colleagues. An Amazon executive wrote that "it appears Groundwork has limited interest in the facts and is focusing on pursuing a pre-determined narrative." In a November 16 statement on its website, the company called the report deeply flawed and false, said Groundwork included products that were not actually on sale, and said it cited prices higher than what customers actually paid. Amazon's own check of the same items found that 98 percent went on sale at prices equal to or lower than pre-sale prices.

The loudest fight is over data that appears in neither version of the report. Groundwork originally tracked Prime Day 2026 as well, then removed it, and Amazon says the data was dropped because it did not fit the group's conclusions. Amazon also says it strengthened its sale-event guardrails in 2026 so advertised deals almost always beat prior prices, while Groundwork says Prime Day came out because the event is limited to Prime members and the holiday sales are not. For a shopper, the residue is narrower than the argument. The struck-through price on a deal page is a claim, the 30-day price history is the receipt, and Amazon's own shopping assistant will show that history on the item page before the money moves.

Sources

The conversation

A little more perspective.

Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.

The conversation.

Loading comments…

Keep your curiosity going.

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we might make a commission — it never changes what you pay. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.