Gupta Receives 235 Months For Pannun Murder Plot
A Manhattan judge closed the case on a guilty plea, and the accusations against a second man remain accusations on paper.
Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague
The judgment closes the Southern District case against Gupta on his guilty plea, and the accusations against Vikash Yadav remain allegations in the court papers.
Judge Victor Marrero sentenced Nikhil Gupta to 235 months in prison on November 20 in a Manhattan courtroom. Gupta, who's 55 and an Indian national, stood in the Southern District of New York and heard the number read as the judgment of the court. The term runs 19 years and seven months.
The number sits at the bottom of the case's sentencing guidelines range, which ran from 235 to 293 months. Prosecutors with the Manhattan U.S. Attorney's office had recommended a sentence of about 24 years. Marrero imposed the floor of the range instead, and the judgment closed the Southern District case against Gupta himself.
Gupta's guilty plea in February removed any trial on the three counts in the case. He pleaded guilty to murder-for-hire, conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire, and conspiracy to commit money laundering. A sentencing on a plea follows a fixed sequence, and November 20 was the last step of it, nine months after the plea was entered.
Court papers name the target as Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, a dual U.S. and Canadian citizen who works as a lawyer at Sikhs for Justice in New York. Pannun advocates for a sovereign Sikh state in northern India. The prosecution's theory placed a price on that advocacy, and the papers describe a plot to kill him on U.S. soil.
The payment record in the court papers is specific, because Gupta and Vikash Yadav arranged to have $15,000 in cash delivered to a purported hitman. The man who took the cash was an undercover U.S. law enforcement officer. The plot ended at that delivery, with the cash in government hands.
Yadav's position in the case is different from Gupta's, and the distinction matters. Prosecutors accuse Yadav, an Indian government official, of plotting with Gupta to kill Pannun. Those accusations rest in the court papers as allegations. No plea and no verdict stand against Yadav in this record, and the November 20 judgment resolved nothing about him.
The arithmetic of the term is plain on the record. Gupta is 55 years old, and a 235-month sentence runs 19 years and seven months, so the term reaches into his mid-seventies. The guidelines range the court worked from began at the number Marrero imposed and ran to 293 months, and the prosecution's recommendation of about 24 years sat near the top of it.
Pannun attended the sentencing and addressed the court in person. He told the court he was grateful to the United States for prosecuting Gupta. He also said he would keep advocating for Sikh sovereignty, which is the work the court papers say the plot was built to stop.
U.S. and Canadian authorities have described the plot as part of a broader effort to target Indian dissidents. The Gupta case is one prosecution inside that description, built on one payment, one undercover officer, and one plea. The court record proves this single instance on this single defendant's own admissions, and the broader pattern remains the authorities' account, printed here as their account.
The case strained ties between India and the United States while it ran. A murder plot against a U.S. citizen, prosecuted in a Manhattan courtroom and attributed in court papers to work alongside an Indian government official, carries weight that a sentence alone doesn't discharge. The diplomatic file stays open after the criminal one closes.
Gupta begins his 235-month term on the record of his own guilty plea, and the file on Yadav stays where the hearing left it. The accusations against him remain allegations in the court papers, untested by any plea or verdict, and the broader effort the authorities describe has no second judgment in this district to stand beside this one.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.