Nicalis Pulls Undisclosed AI Music From Isaac Expansion
A GTA-themed daily run hid seven Suno-made songs in the launch build. The metadata named the tool, and Friday's patch took the music out.
Repentance+ didn't fall over its expansion. It fell over 14 audio files in a joke seed that nobody had audited or disclosed.
Nicalis shipped a patch Friday night that strips undisclosed AI-generated music out of The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+.
Players found the songs inside a Grand Theft Auto-themed daily run, seed V1CE BSMT, that was built to coincide with GTA 6's launch week. The run carried seven full songs plus derivative intros and outros, 14 files in total, and several files carried metadata that read 'made with Suno,' the AI music generator. One track's creation date was October 30, less than three weeks before the November 19 launch.
The disclosure was the problem as much as the music. The Steam listing showed no AI-generated content disclosure, and Valve requires developers to describe AI content shipped in a game, sound included. Series creator Edmund McMillen said Saturday that he hadn't known how the music got into the launch build.
The fix landed fast. Nicalis deployed a critical-fixes build at 10:11 p.m. GMT on Friday that removed the music on PC, and the studio said the build was already with Microsoft, Nintendo, and Sony for the console versions. It also pledged to make console players eligible for the same discount PC players received.
The store page shows the cost. Recent Steam reviews ran between 8 and 9 percent positive in the counts different outlets published, deep inside Overwhelmingly Negative, and the complaints didn't stop at the music. Players cited crashes, broken mods, and a pricing split that charged console owners a 9.99 dollar upgrade for an expansion PC players had received free in November 2024, with the Switch 2 retail edition priced at 69.99 dollars.
The same patch fixed a Larynx and Car Battery interaction bug and a set of mod-compatibility problems, and it continued the studio's netcode and stability work. Repentance+ is a large expansion on any measure, with the game now counting more than 700 items, 34 playable characters, and over 120 bosses, which is why a hidden daily run could carry 14 audio files nobody senior had signed off.
The lesson is an audit lesson. A novelty seed is still shipped content, the disclosure rule doesn't carve out jokes, and in this case the files' own metadata told the story before anyone at the studio did.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.