$2 / month

Comment and reply across TML.

Start or manage membership

Most pulsed

Latest from other desks

tml.the modern leap
Money / Crypto

Judge Acquits Peraire-Bueno Brothers In Ethereum Exploit Case

A federal judge in Manhattan acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on November 16, ruling that prosecutors never proved the lie wire fraud requires, and she directed the clerk to close the first criminal case over an Ethereum MEV exploit.

TML Markets DeskNov 19, 5:29 PM ET · 3 min read

Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague

Marble columns at a federal courthouse (archive). The Peraire-Bueno case was decided in Manhattan federal court, in a 46-page opinion that closes the case. Photo via Wikimedia Commons.
Summary

The bots lost the money in 12 seconds. The court spent 46 pages explaining why that was not wire fraud.

Tap a passage. React to the part that matters.

U.S. District Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on November 16, 2026, in a 46-page opinion. The Manhattan ruling grants the MIT-educated brothers a judgment of acquittal on wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. The opinion, filed in case 24-CR-293, directs the court clerk to close the case, and a judge's acquittal leaves the government no second trial and no appeal.

The underlying trade lasted about 12 seconds in April 2023, inside one Ethereum block interval. Pending transactions wait in a public queue called the mempool, and automated bots scan the queue for maximal extractable value, the profit available from the order of transactions inside a block. Sandwich bots run the common version of that play. A bot spots a large pending buy, buys the same token just ahead of it, lets the victim's order lift the price and sells into the rise.

The brothers reversed that hunt with eight bait transactions, according to the court's opinion. Their validator received a block from a relay called Ultrasound that carried the bots' sandwich trades, and the validator signed the block's header with two crucial fields set to zero. The relay never checked the fields and released the block's contents anyway. The brothers built a replacement block that kept the bots' purchases and swapped the bait for transactions dumping the tokens the bots had just bought, so the exit the bots counted on had already collapsed.

Losses landed fast and mostly stayed landed. The bots lost about 25 million dollars, the brothers' validator was penalized about 1 ether, and only one wallet holding about 3 million dollars of the proceeds was ever frozen. The brothers had moved the rest out by October 2023. Federal prosecutors charged them in May 2024, and the case became the government's first criminal prosecution of a so-called MEV exploit.

AdFour office chairs in a rowFor businessesAmazon Business is Amazon’s purchasing store for companies, with business accounts and quantity ordering.Register with Amazon Business

A jury heard the case first and couldn't decide it. The trial ran nearly four weeks in the fall of 2025, jurors deadlocked after deliberations, and Clarke declared a mistrial in November 2025. The defense then asked the judge to rule on the evidence itself. Her answer turned on the element wire fraud can't proceed without, a material misrepresentation, and she found that prosecutors never established one at trial.

The opinion works through the alleged lies one mechanism at a time. The bait trades carried no promise, Clarke wrote, because no trader who places a transaction in the public mempool would agree to be sandwiched, and the government offered no evidence that a pending trade promises to be bundled. The falsified signature failed for a practical reason. The relay never checked the zeroed fields, so the signature "had no effect on the behavior of its recipient." Her summary of the network itself is one sentence. "It is a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use."

Clarke also separated legality from approval in language she drew from a 2022 Second Circuit ruling, which calls conduct "improper, objectionable, or even despicable" and finds that label alone can't satisfy wire fraud. She acknowledged the brothers concealed their plans and may have frustrated the spirit of the relay software's design. The money laundering conspiracy count depended on proceeds of wire fraud, so it fell with the fraud counts, and the sandwich bot operators who lost about 25 million dollars hold their losses with no criminal case standing behind them.

Sources

The conversation

A little more perspective.

Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.

The conversation.

Loading comments…

Keep your curiosity going.

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we might make a commission — it never changes what you pay. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.