$2 / month

Comment and reply across TML.

Start or manage membership

Most pulsed

Latest from other desks

tml.the modern leap
Money / Rug Pulls

Attacker Drains Kava Hard Lend Through Dormant BUSD Market

A lending market for a stablecoin nobody mints anymore let one wallet borrow 53.9 million KAVA against collateral the protocol valued at two hundred-millionths of a cent, and the lenders who funded those loans still have no repayment plan in front of them.

TML Markets DeskNov 21, 3:16 PM ET · 3 min read

Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague

The Kava network logo.
Summary

The market for a dead stablecoin stayed open with a 50 percent collateral factor, and the guard that should have stopped the drain refused a supply of exactly zero while accepting two units.

Tap a passage. React to the part that matters.

An attacker borrowed 53.9 million KAVA from the Hard Lend protocol on November 14 by inflating a dormant BUSD market. The market should have been empty, because Paxos stopped issuing BUSD in February 2023 after a New York regulator ordered a halt and trading in the token wound down across the industry. Hard Lend, the lending protocol on the Kava chain, never removed it. The market sat open with a 50 percent collateral factor, and a wind-down proposal that passed on September 28 of this year left that setting untouched.

The exploit worked because the protocol measured collateral against a supply figure the attacker controlled. According to Kava's incident report and the post-mortem analyses built from it, the attacker shrank the net supply of BUSD inside the market to two base units, a balance worth $0.00000002. A guard in the code refused a supply of exactly zero, and two units passed. With almost no BUSD left in the market, the supply index that prices deposits climbed from 2.762 to 671,186.99 in about three minutes, a jump of roughly 243,000 times. A deposit of 5,192.65 BUSD then read on the protocol's books as about 1.26 billion BUSD, close to $1.25 billion of paper collateral.

Against that paper the attacker borrowed real assets and liquidated the position in a loop, running 127 borrow and self-liquidation rounds across 98 minutes, from 04:04 to 05:42 UTC on November 14. Gross borrowing reached 55.2 million KAVA, worth about $3.76 million at the pre-attack price of $0.068, and the module account that held lender deposits fell from 55.33 million KAVA to 0.19 KAVA. Kava's own accounting puts the net extraction at 53.9 million KAVA. About 49.2 million KAVA crossed to BNB Chain through the LayerZero bridge, and roughly 48.4 million of it was sold for about $2.09 million. A separate transfer of 612,416 USDT sits blocked at the Relay bridge under a BLOCKED_WALLET flag, and nobody has said publicly whether it will be released or seized.

The response lagged the theft by hours, since Kava's first public word on the incident came at 11:28 UTC, more than seven hours after the borrowing started. The Axelar bridge was paused at 14:05 UTC, after the funds had already left through LayerZero. In South Korea, where Kava has a large holder base, Upbit, Bithumb and Coinone suspended KAVA deposits and withdrawals, and Bithumb added an investment-warning designation on November 16. That designation starts a review that can end in delisting, with a decision expected between December 14 and December 18.

AdFour office chairs in a rowFor businessesAmazon Business is Amazon’s purchasing store for companies, with business accounts and quantity ordering.Register with Amazon Business

Governance is now deciding what Hard Lend becomes, and Proposal 223, open for voting from November 16 to November 23, would freeze borrowing, cut supply and borrow caps to zero and restore a $10 minimum deposit. At the last published tally the measure stood at 100 percent yes, with 89,362,171 KAVA voting for, 1,785 against and 41 veto votes, on turnout of 70.12 percent against a 20 percent quorum. A second measure, Proposal 224, stood at 99.41 percent yes. Kava says the bug is patched and that some funds were frozen, without disclosing an amount, and deposits were, in its words, largely unaffected.

What remains open is the lenders' money. The pool is owed roughly 55.2 million KAVA, and as of November 18 Kava had published no repayment or compensation plan. The protocol that failed here was no obscure fork. Hard Lend is Kava's own lending market, and the hole sat in a market for a token its issuer had abandoned almost three years earlier. Anyone with funds in a lending protocol can check the same exposure in minutes, because the markets still listed, the collateral factors still attached to dead tokens and the guards that refuse zero but accept two units are all visible on chain before an attacker reads them.

Sources

The conversation

A little more perspective.

Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.

The conversation.

Loading comments…

Keep your curiosity going.

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we might make a commission — it never changes what you pay. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.