Leipzig Judge Offers Movie2k Defendant Dismissal For Bitcoin
Leipzig Regional Court Judge Karsten Nickel has proposed dismissing the money laundering case against Josef F., the alleged operator of the Movie2k piracy site, if he transfers 40,000 bitcoin to authorities and pays 38 million euros in compensation, and prosecutors estimate he still holds about 56,000 bitcoin.
Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague
A Leipzig judge will dismiss a money laundering trial if the defendant surrenders 40,000 of the roughly 56,000 bitcoin prosecutors say he holds, and the December 3 hearing decides whether the state takes the deal or the proof fight.
Josef F. can end his money laundering trial in Leipzig by handing the court 40,000 bitcoin, because Judge Karsten Nickel of the Leipzig Regional Court put that proposal on the table in a trial that opened in February. The terms reach past the coins, since the 43-year-old defendant would also pay 38 million euros in compensation to potential victims. He'd also give up any claim to the roughly 2.64 billion euros Saxony already raised by selling bitcoin he handed over in 2024, while public broadcaster MDR reported the offer from the court and Saxony's Office of the Public Prosecutor General confirmed it to the dpa news agency.
The arithmetic explains why a judge is bargaining at this scale, because prosecutors estimate Josef F. still holds about 56,000 bitcoin. That holding is worth around 3.57 billion dollars at a bitcoin price near 64,000 dollars, so a 40,000 coin transfer leaves him roughly 16,000 coins worth about 940 million euros. The 40,000 coins themselves price between 2.36 billion and 2.6 billion euros depending on the day's market, and a co-defendant faces a smaller version of the same choice. His offer is built on 600 bitcoin and 17 million euros, and his lawyer told MDR she could accept it.
The coins came from a streaming site that shut down in 2013, because prosecutors allege Movie2k's operators took in millions of euros in advertising revenue and subscription payments. The operators put much of that money into bitcoin while it traded far below current prices, and the copyright charges in the case are too old to prosecute. The February trial runs on 146 counts of commercial money laundering and on tax evasion charges instead, and Josef F. was arrested abroad in 2023 before he handed over nearly 50,000 bitcoin in early 2024. Saxony sold those coins later that year for about 2.64 billion euros, and the money sits in a state judicial treasury account that still belongs to him until a court reaches a final ruling. The waiver in the judge's proposal carries real weight for that reason.
Nickel has moved toward this outcome in steps, and his doubts are part of the record, since he floated a suspended sentence in April if the defendant confessed and gave investigators access to another 57,000 bitcoin. He has since questioned whether all the coins in the defendant's accounts came from illegal activity, because legal and illegal bitcoin may have sat mixed in the same wallets. That mixing is the proof problem at the center of the trial, and blockchain analytics firm Arkham said last year that German authorities had failed to seize some 45,000 bitcoin linked to the site. The Arkham figure shows how much of the money trail still sits outside the state's hands.
For businesses
Amazon Business is Amazon’s purchasing store for companies, with business accounts and quantity ordering.Register with Amazon BusinessNobody has signed anything yet, because the Dresden prosecutors' office and the defense are both reviewing the proposal while the trial stands adjourned until December 3. The case could close before Christmas if the parties agree, and the offer lands in a changed legal climate. German lawmakers have approved new powers that let customs officials seize assets of doubtful origin, crypto included, without opening a criminal case first, so a defendant weighing whether to surrender 40,000 coins is weighing them against a state that's widening its tools for taking coins it can't trace to a lawful source.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.