Lindsay Clancy Retrial Set for March 29, 2027
A Plymouth Superior Court judge set Lindsay Clancy's retrial for March 29, 2027, at a hearing on Monday, November 16, 2026. Her first trial ended in September with a jury deadlocked 11 to 1 in favor of finding her not criminally responsible for the January 2023 deaths of her three children in Duxbury. A status hearing follows on December 30 and a final pretrial conference on February 18.
Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague
The retrial is set for March 29, 2027, before the same judge, who retires in June. What prosecutors haven't settled publicly is whether plea talks happen before a second jury is seated.
Lindsay Clancy will be tried a second time on March 29, 2027, in the deaths of her three children, after a Plymouth Superior Court judge set the date at a hearing on Monday, November 16, 2026. Judge William Sullivan scheduled jury empanelment for March 29, with a status hearing on December 30, 2026, and a final pretrial conference on February 18, 2027. Prosecutors confirmed in court that they're pursuing a new jury trial, and they said the charges require one — an indication they'll again seek first-degree murder convictions.
Clancy, a former labor and delivery nurse, is charged in the January 2023 strangulation deaths of her children at the family home in Duxbury: Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months. She hasn't denied the killings. Her defense argues she shouldn't be held criminally responsible because of her mental condition at the time. At her first trial she faced three counts of first-degree murder, and the jury was allowed to consider lesser charges in its deliberations. If she's convicted at the retrial, she faces life in prison.
The first trial ended in September 2026 without a verdict. After more than a month of testimony, the 12-person jury deadlocked 11 to 1, with 11 jurors favoring a finding that Clancy wasn't criminally responsible and one holdout juror preventing that verdict. Sullivan declared a mistrial on September 4. The split matters for what comes next: prosecutors are taking a case to a second jury after the first one came within one vote of acquitting her on responsibility grounds, and both sides know it.
Since the mistrial, defense attorney Kevin Reddington has filed a series of motions aimed at stopping a second trial, and Sullivan has rejected each of them. The judge denied a motion seeking an acquittal on October 1. On November 9, he rejected a bid to dismiss the charges on double jeopardy grounds — ruling that the jury's deadlock, a hung jury, is the classic case of manifest necessity that permits a mistrial and a retrial — and he denied a request for records concerning the holdout juror. Clancy's side is appealing the rulings, though her lawyer has said the appeal won't delay the trial date.
The calendar itself was contested. The defense pushed for an early 2027 date, and it had a structural reason: Sullivan faces mandatory retirement in June 2027, when he turns 70, and the defense wants the trial heard by the judge who has handled the case. Prosecutors first pushed for a May date to accommodate other pending cases, then switched to late April. Sullivan picked March 29 instead and told both sides, in substance, that retrials are routine work: "We've all done retrials." Plymouth County Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague said the state was prepared to select a jury trial date. District Attorney Timothy Cruz didn't appear in court on Monday.
Two things remain unsettled, and both could move the date. Prosecutors haven't said outright whether every charge from the first indictment carries into the second trial, beyond signaling that the charges require a jury. And legal experts note that a retrial date set in November isn't set in stone: prosecutorial decisions or plea negotiations between now and March could alter or end the case before a jury is seated. Cruz, who didn't appear on Monday, is the official who could start those negotiations.
The machinery now runs on the court's dates. The parties return on December 30 for a status hearing on trial logistics, security and media preparations, then again on February 18 for the final pretrial conference. On March 29, 2027, a new jury is empaneled in Plymouth Superior Court to hear, for a second time, whether Lindsay Clancy was criminally responsible for the deaths of her three children — the question 12 jurors spent seven days on in September and couldn't answer unanimously.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.