Court Acquits Eisenberg, Saying Mango Had No Rules To Break
The jury called it fraud. The judge read the platform's rulebook, found it empty, vacated two counts on venue, and acquitted on the third.
No rules on the platform meant no lie to the platform.
A federal judge has thrown out every criminal conviction against Avraham Eisenberg, the trader who drained $110 million from Mango Markets in October 2022.
The trade itself was never in dispute. On October 11, 2022, Eisenberg drove the price of MNGO, Mango's token, up over 1,300 percent on thin markets. He then used the inflated position as collateral and borrowed about $110 million of other users' deposits out of the platform. Mango Markets was a permissionless exchange on Solana, and its code let the withdrawals through.
A jury in the Southern District of New York convicted him on April 18, 2024, on commodities fraud, commodities manipulation, and wire fraud. The conviction made the case the government's flagship answer to a question DeFi had posed for years: when the code allows a trade, can the trade still be a crime?
Judge Arun Subramanian's 35-page opinion, issued May 23, 2025, answered the case on narrower grounds. He vacated the two commodities counts on venue. Eisenberg traded from Puerto Rico, and the court held that a vendor's monitoring work in Manhattan and a Poughkeepsie user's failed withdrawal weren't essential conduct in New York. "He didn't make trades in New York, call or email anyone in New York, or go to New York in connection with his scheme," the opinion says.
For businesses
Amazon Business is Amazon’s purchasing store for companies, with business accounts and quantity ordering.Register with Amazon BusinessThe wire fraud count fell further. The judge entered a judgment of acquittal, holding that fraud needs a material false statement and Mango had given him nothing to lie against. The platform had no terms of service, no rule against manipulation, and no requirement that a borrower repay. Gaming a system that posts no rules isn't, on this record, a false statement to it.
The fight isn't over. The government has appealed to the Second Circuit, and the SEC and CFTC civil cases still stood when the ruling landed. Mango Markets itself has shut down. Eisenberg stays in federal prison regardless: in a separate case built on material found on his devices after his arrest, he pleaded guilty and drew 52 months on May 1, 2025. The Mango ruling erases the fraud convictions. It doesn't open his cell door.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.