Steynberg Owes Record CFTC Penalty And Restitution
A Texas federal judge ordered Cornelius Johannes Steynberg to pay $1,733,838,372 in restitution and the same amount again as a civil penalty in April 2023. The CFTC called the penalty the largest in its history and warned in the same statement that an order on paper isn't money in victims' hands.
The bot never traded. The judgment is real, and the recovery is the open question.
The largest penalty in CFTC history splits into two equal piles of $1,733,838,372, and neither pile has been paid. One pile is restitution, owed to the people who sent Mirror Trading International their bitcoin. The other is a civil monetary penalty owed to the United States. Judge Lee Yeakel signed the order on April 27, 2023 in the Western District of Texas, and the CFTC called the penalty the highest it has ever won in any case.
Mirror Trading International ran from May 2018 to March 2021 as an unregistered commodity pool that took in at least 29,421 bitcoin, worth more than $1.7 billion in March 2021. More than 23,000 participants were in the United States. The pitch was a proprietary trading bot working the foreign exchange markets for returns near 10 percent a month, and the CFTC's findings say the bot didn't trade as claimed and the bitcoin was misappropriated instead.
Recruiting did the distribution work that trading was supposed to do. The pool paid out in a multilevel structure, so early members earned by bringing in later members whose deposits funded the statements everyone watched climb. Mirror Trading sits in liquidation in South Africa, where a court declared it an unlawful pyramid scheme.
The CFTC filed its complaint on June 30, 2022, and Steynberg never answered it into a trial. The April 2023 order is a default judgment. It finds him liable for fraud in connection with retail foreign currency transactions, fraud as an associated person of a commodity pool operator and registration violations, and it bars him permanently from CFTC registration and from trading in CFTC-regulated markets.
For businesses
Amazon Business is Amazon’s purchasing store for companies, with business accounts and quantity ordering.Register with Amazon BusinessSteynberg himself has been in custody in Brazil since late December 2021, held on an Interpol warrant, and South African law enforcement lists him as a fugitive from its own case. The judgment was entered in Texas against a defendant in a Brazilian cell, which is the practical problem the CFTC flagged in its own statement: an order doesn't guarantee recovery when the assets sit outside the court's reach.
For participants, the restitution pile is a claim against whatever the CFTC can collect, and collection runs through a separate South African liquidation with its own creditor process. The $3.4 billion measures what the scheme took in and what the statute allowed the court to stack on top. It doesn't measure what anyone has gotten back.
Sources
- CFTC wins record $3.4B penalty payment in Bitcoin-related fraud case, Cointelegraph, reporting the CFTC's April 27, 2023 statement on Judge Lee Yeakel's order, the $1,733,838,372 restitution and $1,733,838,372 civil penalty and the 29,421 bitcoin intake
- CFTC fraud case results in record penalty, Investment Executive, reporting the order's findings on the fake trading bot, the multilevel scheme, Steynberg's detention in Brazil and the scheme's May 2018 to March 2021 run
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.