Poster Sells Couch Her Brother-In-Law Promised Away
A woman mentioned a remodel in the family chat, and her brother-in-law gave her couch set to his girlfriend before she'd sold it. She'd already listed it, two buyers bit within a day, and her fix was to post the listing where everyone could see the price.
The couch wasn't the problem. The problem was a gift somebody else had already given away.
A poster on r/AmItheAsshole says a passing mention of her remodel got her couch promised away inside the family group chat.
Per her account, her brother-in-law told his girlfriend she could have the couch set for free. Nobody had asked the poster's permission, and the girlfriend started planning around furniture that wasn't hers to give.
The catch is that the poster had already listed the set online for several hundred dollars. Two Marketplace buyers wanted it within a day of the listing, which turned a family misunderstanding into an actual sale with actual money attached.
The girlfriend, meanwhile, had measured her living room for the set. That's the detail that makes the story sting. She wasn't scheming, per the post. She'd simply believed the person who told her the couch was hers.
The poster's fix was procedural rather than loud. She planned to drop the listing itself into the family chat, price visible, so the record showed the couch was for sale and had never been a gift. Paper trails end arguments that memories keep restarting.
Family chats run on an honor system, and the system breaks the moment somebody spends somebody else's property as a favor. A screenshot of a price tag isn't rude. It's the receipt.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.