Ripple Lawyer Alderoty Backs Agency Rules Over Clarity Act
Stuart Alderoty, Ripple's chief legal officer, told the Capitol Crypto Forum on November 19 that the SEC and CFTC can carry crypto policy for the next two years, and he doesn't expect the Clarity Act to return in the next Congress.
Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague
The lawyer who fought the SEC for years now argues the agency rulebook is the industry's best shelter, because a rule built on public comment is harder for the next administration to tear up than a lawsuit ever was.
Stuart Alderoty told a Washington forum on November 19 that regulators, not Congress, will carry crypto policy. Alderoty is Ripple's chief legal officer and president of the National Cryptocurrency Association, and he spoke at the Capitol Crypto Forum, an event hosted by The Hill and The Block, where his subject was the Clarity Act, the market structure bill that stalled in Congress, and his answer was that the industry shouldn't wait for it.
Elizabeth Warren's expected rise to lead the Senate Banking Committee drew his sharpest line of the day. "I don't think Elizabeth Warren is going to set crypto policy in this country," Alderoty said. "She'll probably focus on oversight and hearings, which I think will be a short-term distraction." He described Warren as overtly anti-crypto and said he expects other lawmakers to take the wheel on crypto policy.
"I think the emphasis and the focus is going to move to the SEC and the CFTC," he said, and he added collaborations with the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency to the list. Asked whether agency action would be enough for the industry over the next two years without market structure legislation, he answered directly: "I think it's enough, and I think it's really important."
His case rests on how rules get made, because a rule written through public comment and data analysis is hard for a future administration to reverse. A successor has to run its own policymaking process and justify disrupting the market's reliance on the existing rules, and Alderoty contrasted that path with the enforcement era in two sentences. "The Gensler SEC did not do the hard work of rulemaking," he said. "What they decided to do was fall back to regulation by enforcement." Against that record he set the current approach: "This administration is doing the hard work of rulemaking, and that is durable."
For businesses
Amazon Business is Amazon’s purchasing store for companies, with business accounts and quantity ordering.Register with Amazon BusinessThe proposals he's counting on are already in motion, since the SEC's Regulation Crypto Assets proposal of August 18 would create two registration exemptions for crypto offerings, one for up to $5 million over four years and another for up to $75 million in each 12-month period. Its comment period closed on October 20 and it stays a proposal until the Commission votes on a final version, while Ripple filed its own comment letter on October 20 backing the rulemaking path with caveats. The CFTC's October 13 Federal Register notice carries two linked proposals on leveraged retail crypto trades.
Not everyone at the forum shared his confidence in the agencies, since Senator Bernie Moreno said rigorous SEC and CFTC rulemaking could achieve about 80 percent of a crypto regulatory framework while he still favors passing the Clarity Act. Representative French Hill warned that agency rules can't replace legislation, because they lack the same legal permanence and can face court challenges, so the durability Alderoty prizes is the very point his critics dispute.
Alderoty gave the Clarity Act a crowded postmortem, citing the Senate's decision not to advance the House-passed bill, the split between stablecoin and market structure legislation, and disputes over rewards. Ethics concerns around the Trump family's crypto ties ultimately overwhelmed the conversation, he said, and he doesn't expect a version of the bill to be reintroduced in the coming Congress, pointing to a packed calendar and the 2028 presidential election, though pieces of it could ride inside tax legislation or other bills. His closing advice concerned the industry's own pitch, since lawmakers hear competing groups argue esoteric issues, and he likened the confusion to a policymaker hearing fishermen argue about tackle and tides. "Crypto is a policy issue," he said. "It's not a political issue."
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.