Desert Lakes Drew Nobody Without Stone For Tools
A 1,500-kilometer survey across the Rub' al Khali found ancient lake beds in a desert that held no workable stone, and the empty map rewrites what early settlement required.
Water alone didn't settle the Empty Quarter. The ground had to offer rock a person could chip, and across most of the transect it didn't.
A 1,500-kilometer survey of Arabia's Rub' al Khali found lake deposits at 55 sites and not one stone tool or piece of workable rock.
The study, published in Nature and led by Jeffrey Rose, investigated 125 localities across the largest sand sea on Earth, a desert of about 650,000 square kilometers. The team recorded palaeolake deposits at 55 of those localities, dated to roughly 125,000 to 70,000 years ago. Ground visibility along the transect ran above 95 percent, so the second result can't be explained by sand cover: the survey found zero lithic artefacts and zero knappable raw material anywhere along the route.
The two maps explain each other once they're laid together. About 57 percent of the terrain within reach of ancient water sits on geological formations that carry no stone suitable for knapping, the chipping process that turns rock into blades and points. When the researchers added raw-material availability to their site-location model, its accuracy at separating likely settlement ground from empty ground rose from 0.695 to 0.768 on the standard discrimination scale.
Earlier work in Arabia has often treated water as the master variable, the resource that decided where early humans could live between humid phases. This survey keeps water in the model and still watches it fail on its own. A lake shore without chippable stone offered drinking water and game, but it couldn't supply the tools a group needed to hunt, butcher and stay.
The result has limits the authors state plainly. One transect, even a 1,500-kilometer one, samples a fraction of the sand sea, and the lake dates carry the uncertainty of the sediments they came from. What the study settles is narrower and harder: in this desert, at this scale, settlement tracked two resources at once, and any map drawn from water alone will mark empty lakesides as homes.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.