Starbucks Sugar Free Drinks Draw Federal Labeling Lawsuit
A proposed class action filed in Florida says eight Starbucks drinks sold as sugar-free carry 13 to 21 grams of sugar in a venti serving.
Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague
The complaint turns on one gap, between the words sugar-free on the menu board and the grams the filing counts in the cup.
A venti drink sold as sugar-free carries 13 to 21 grams of sugar, a new federal complaint alleges. The proposed class action, Stewart v. Starbucks Corporation, reached the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida on November 16, and it names eight Starbucks Sugar-Free Protein Beverages. The figures in the complaint are allegations at this stage, because no class has been certified and Starbucks hasn't answered in court on the public record the filing appears in.
The case sits inside a definitional fight over sweeteners that's running across the food industry. Two more suits reached the Eastern District of New York in the same filing window, because one, filed on November 16, says BODYARMOR Flash IV drinks marketed as zero sugar contain allulose while the other, filed on November 13, says five Lewis Bake Shop breads labeled 0g SUGAR contain allulose. Allulose is the sweetener the two complaints put at the center of their labeling dispute.
For a buyer watching sugar intake, the label is the whole decision at the counter, and a protein drink picked up on a work break carries its sugar count in the nutrition panel while the complaint says the name on the menu board tells a different story from the grams in the serving. The proposed class, as the complaint defines it, covers people who bought the products, and the court decides later whether any class is certified.
The same filing window carried a fourth food label case, because a suit filed on November 13 says Blue Diamond Growers' Smokehouse Almonds are mislabeled, and the archive behind the list has a limit of its own, since RECAP holds only filings someone has downloaded from the federal court system, so the 23 cases are the visible slice of the week's filings, not the whole of them.
The Starbucks filing was one of 23 consumer class actions that reached federal court from November 10 to 16 and surfaced in the public RECAP archive, the repository CourtListener runs on federal court downloads. The week's filings also took on marketing texts, customer data sales, and a mandatory network fee. None of the 23 has a certified class or a settlement, and there's nothing for buyers to file in any of them at this stage.
What happens next runs on the court's clock, because Starbucks answers the complaint or moves against it and the definitional question rides with the case. What sugar-free has to mean on a menu board gets argued on the filing record, and buyers who kept receipts hold the paper a case like this one asks for if it ever gets that far.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.