Straus Recalls Ice Cream Pints Over Metal Fragments
Straus Family Creamery is recalling six ice cream products sold nationwide over the possible presence of metal fragments, and Mesa County Public Health says no injuries have been reported and shoppers should check the best-by dates printed on the bottom of each container.
Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague
The whole test is printed on the bottom of the tub.
The recall notice names six products and six dates. Straus Family Creamery is recalling pints and quarts of ice cream because the products may contain metal fragments, and the list covers Vanilla Bean pints, Strawberry in pints and quarts, Cookie Dough pints, Dutch Chocolate quarts and Mint Chip pints. Each container carries a best-by date in late December 2026, printed in black on the bottom of the container, and the products were distributed nationwide.
The dates are the check that matters at the freezer door, because Vanilla Bean pints carry best-by dates of December 23 and December 28, 2026, while Strawberry quarts are dated December 24 and Strawberry pints December 25. Cookie Dough pints are dated December 26, Dutch Chocolate quarts December 27 and Mint Chip pints December 30, so a shopper doesn't need a lot number or a receipt, since the flavor, the container size and the date on the bottom settle whether a tub is in the recall.
Mesa County Public Health published the alert on Thursday because the products may have been sold in Mesa County, and the county's notice states the wider fact plainly, since to date no injuries have been reported in connection with these products. The Food and Drug Administration carries the full product list on its recall pages, and the county directs shoppers there for the complete list beyond the six items in its alert.
The instruction for anyone holding a recalled tub is short, because shoppers should check the freezer and throw the product out or return it to the place of purchase, while anyone who has eaten the ice cream and has concerns should contact a doctor right away. The notice doesn't describe how metal fragments may have entered the products, and it doesn't name a production line or a plant, so those details sit with the company and the FDA listing.
Metal fragments are a recurring reason for ice cream and frozen dessert recalls because the hazard is physical and the fix is binary, since a container is either inside the date list or outside it and there's no cooking step or storage habit that changes the answer. That makes this recall simpler than a contamination case with invisible bacteria, and it also makes the freezer check easy to postpone, because the tub looks and tastes like the product a family bought on purpose.
The county's part in the chain is distribution of the warning itself, because Mesa County Public Health says its role is to share recall information when a product may have been distributed in the county, so the notice reaches as many community members as possible. That system is why a creamery's recall shows up on a Colorado county page on the same day, since the alert travels through county health offices because that's where a shopper who never opens the FDA site still has a chance to see it.
The recalled dates run through the last week of December, which means the check lands in the middle of holiday buying, so a family stocking a freezer for guests this month may hold a December 30 Mint Chip pint without connecting it to a November recall notice. The date on the bottom of the container is the whole test, and it takes ten seconds at the freezer door.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.