$2 / month

Comment and reply across TML.

Start or manage membership

Most pulsed

Latest from other desks

tml.the modern leap
Health / Mental Health

Uncertainty Intolerance Climbs Faster Among College Young Adults

A meta-analysis of 137 studies covering 37,298 college students in the United States and Canada found that intolerance of uncertainty rose steadily from 1992 to 2023 and climbed about three times faster after 2012 than in the two decades before it.

TML Health DeskNov 18, 8:16 PM ET · 3 min read

Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague

Knox Lecture Hall at the University at Buffalo under snow (archive). Photo: Breadchastick, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 3.0).
Summary

The authors say interventions that reduce intolerance of uncertainty already exist for people with anxiety and mood disorders.

Tap a passage. React to the part that matters.

A college student who needs to know exactly what to expect before class is showing the trait this study tracks. Intolerance of uncertainty is the tendency to struggle when important information is missing or an outcome cannot be predicted, and a meta-analysis published Wednesday in JAMA Psychiatry found that the trait increased steadily among college-aged young adults in the United States and Canada between 1992 and 2023, with the sharpest rise beginning around 2012.

The analysis pooled 137 studies with 37,298 participants who completed either the 27-item or the 12-item Intolerance of Uncertainty Scale, drawn from peer-reviewed studies of nonclinical undergraduate samples in the two countries. Mean scores on the long-form scale rose 0.66 points per year across the full period on a scale running from 27 to 135, while short-form scores rose 0.60 points per year from 2005, the first short-form sample year, on a scale running from 12 to 60.

The combined trend works out to growth of 0.04 standard deviations per year, and the slope changes at 2012, since from 2012 to 2023 the trait grew at 0.06 standard deviations per year against 0.02 standard deviations per year from 1992 to 2011. First author Jeroen M. Van Baar of Boston University School of Public Health and senior author Katherine M. Keyes of Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health led the work, which the National Institute of Mental Health supported under grant 5T32MH013043.

"IU is not itself a health outcome or a root cause of disease, but an intermediary cognitive process that contributes to the development of anxiety," Keyes said. People with higher intolerance of uncertainty face greater risk for multiple anxiety and mood disorders, and the authors argue that a trait this unfamiliar outside psychology is less vulnerable to the objection that rising anxiety numbers only reflect greater willingness to report symptoms, because Van Baar noted that young people familiar with the word anxiety may report symptoms more readily while the uncertainty scale asks about a concept most respondents have never been coached to name.

The study cannot say what moved the trait, and the authors present their candidate drivers as context rather than findings, listing increased smartphone and social media use, greater academic pressure, loneliness, economic instability, childhood adversity and the COVID-19 pandemic among the possibilities. Van Baar said the factors are likely intertwined and mutually reinforcing, and he added that any explanation has to account for both the long upward trend since the 1990s and the sharper bend around 2012, which a pandemic that began in 2020 cannot explain on its own.

Every participant was a college student in the United States or Canada in a nonclinical sample, the measure is a self-report questionnaire rather than a diagnosis, and a meta-analysis of published studies can track a population average without showing that any individual student's tolerance changed. What the paper supports is narrower and still useful, because the cognitive building block underneath anxiety has been rising for three decades on a consistent instrument and interventions that reduce intolerance of uncertainty already exist for people with anxiety and mood disorders, which gives campuses and clinicians a defined target.

Sources

The conversation

A little more perspective.

Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.

The conversation.

Loading comments…

Keep your curiosity going.

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we might make a commission — it never changes what you pay. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.