Voyager 1 Confirms Light-Day Crossing With Carrier Signal Only
NASA confirmed the crossing on Thursday from a carrier signal and trajectory calculations, and engineers are still diagnosing a fault that has kept science and engineering data from reaching Earth since November 14.
Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague
Voyager 1 is one light-day from Earth, its science and engineering data has been missing since November 14, and NASA has set no date for the data to return.
Early Thursday at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory, engineers received the signal Voyager 1 had sent a full day earlier. The signal marked the spacecraft's arrival one light-day from Earth, a distance it reached at 5:16 a.m. Eastern on Wednesday, November 18. It carried no measurements and no health report. The radio transmission itself was the whole downlink, a steady carrier with nothing riding on it.
A Deep Space Network antenna in Canberra, Australia, had locked onto the spacecraft on November 14 and found that pattern first. NASA's November 18 mission update says the team became aware that day that the spacecraft had stopped sending science and engineering data. The carrier is the underlying radio transmission that normally carries that data to ground antennas. It kept arriving on schedule while the data stayed missing, and it was still the only thing arriving when the crossing came.
The carrier still tells engineers that Voyager 1 is pointing at Earth. NASA says its presence means the Attitude and Articulation Control computer is doing its job of holding the spacecraft's antenna on target, and the antenna and broadcast equipment still work. The missing data points somewhere else. NASA says the lack of data suggests a fault in the onboard computer that collects information from the spacecraft's subsystems. That computer gathers the science instruments' readings and puts everything into the format the transmitter sends home. The magnetometer and the plasma wave subsystem are the two instruments still switched on, according to NASA's instrument status table, and their readings travel the same data path that has gone quiet. NASA hasn't confirmed a cause.
A test command sent from Earth on a Monday reaches the spacecraft on Tuesday, and the earliest answer reaches Earth on Wednesday. NASA states the arithmetic plainly in its update. A radio wave takes 24 hours to reach the probe, and any signal it sends takes 24 hours to reach Earth. Diagnosing the fault may take weeks or longer at that exchange rate, because every question the team asks costs two days before the reply can be read. Project manager Suzanne Dodd described the same delay in October. "If you want to say 'hello' to Voyager, you send your message and then you go home and you wait two days before you finally get a response," she said.
"We listen to Voyager 1 every day and send commands to the spacecraft weekly," Dodd said in NASA's November 19 release. "It just takes a little longer to communicate than it used to." The listening runs through the Deep Space Network, NASA's system of large antennas at three facilities around the world. The complexes sit in California, Spain, and Australia, spaced so Earth's rotation hands a distant spacecraft from one station to the next. A contact is a scheduled appointment with a moving target, and the network keeps those appointments daily for a spacecraft that answers at the speed of light and no faster.
The Canberra dish that caught the carrier, Deep Space Station 43, stands 73 meters tall and measures 70 meters across. NASA's Canberra complex page says the antenna weighs more than 3,000 tonnes and rotates on a film of oil about 0.17 millimeters thick. Its reflector is built from 1,272 aluminum panels. Workers enlarged it from 64 meters to 70 meters in 1987 so it could hear Voyager 2 at Neptune, and it remains the largest steerable parabolic antenna in the Southern Hemisphere. That sensitivity is what a carrier at this distance requires. The signal left a spacecraft 25.9 billion kilometers away, and a dish the size of a small stadium pulled it out of the noise.
In October, Voyager 1 went silent for two scheduled contacts and came back before any command could reach it. The Deep Space Network heard nothing on October 18 or October 19, and the signal reappeared on October 20, a day later, before the team had sent a single troubleshooting command. Engineers later determined that one group of thrusters had gone offline and the backups had turned on. The swap is programmed into the spacecraft as fault protection. It directs Voyager 1 to put itself into a safe, stable configuration and pause normal operations while engineers work out what happened. At one light-day, that built-in judgment carries more of the mission than it used to. No instruction from Earth can arrive inside a day, so the spacecraft's first response to trouble is always its own.
Ground controllers have received this exact symptom before. In 2023, Voyager 1 sent a carrier signal and no data, and NASA says that fault was caused by one of the onboard computers. The team resolved it, and NASA says the experience from that repair is informing the approach to the current fault. Engineers are also investigating whether the November data stoppage connects to the October communications gap. The spacecraft resumed communication by itself in October and operated normally until November 14. NASA presents the possible connection as a question under investigation, and it hasn't reported a finding either way.
Trajectory models built from years of measurements fixed the crossing time before any signal arrived. NASA says engineers know the probe's distance from Earth from those models, and the spacecraft travels at a consistent speed on a known trajectory with no way to change that speed. An engineering fault can't move the milestone, so the team confirmed one light-day from the carrier and the calculations. NASA held its celebration on November 19, a day after the crossing, because the signal confirming it needed a day to get home. "Traveling a light-day is a singular feat for a spacecraft," said Joe Westlake, director of NASA's Heliophysics Division. The confirmation delay is now built into every milestone the mission has left.
Light reaches the Moon in 1.3 seconds and Neptune in four hours and ten minutes, and it needs a full day to reach Voyager 1. NASA puts the exact distance at 16,094,799,096 miles, or 25,902,068,356 kilometers. The spacecraft took 49 years, two months, and 11 days to open that gap after its 1977 launch, cruising at nearly 38,000 miles per hour through interstellar space. A schoolchild who watched that launch is now near retirement, and the engineers flying the spacecraft send it instructions that arrive when the spacecraft is a day older than the machine they aimed at. Every exchange starts from a position report that's already history.
NASA hasn't named a cause for the data fault, and it hasn't set a date for data to return. The agency says the mission expects to eventually lose both Voyager spacecraft to unresolvable engineering issues, and it also says the team plans to keep them operating and returning science for as long as it can. Power narrows that window a little each year. The radioisotope generators lose about 4 watts annually, and a September effort that swapped three devices for lower-power alternatives is expected to keep the current instruments running until at least the spacecraft's 50th launch anniversary next summer. Until a downlink carries data again, the carrier is the only evidence arriving, and it lands a full day after Voyager 1 sent it.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.