Drivers Pay More For Gas Without Driving Less
Gasoline use from March through early November ran almost exactly level with last year, while prices stood 31 percent higher and households paid up to $730 more for fuel.
Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague
Two federal measures say driving never fell, and the next mileage release will either confirm the flat line or show the cutback arriving a season late.
Drivers heading to work, school and errands this year burned about as much gasoline as they did last year. Federal data show fuel use from early March through early November ran almost exactly in line with the same stretch a year earlier, even as prices climbed sharply after the Iran war began in late February. That flat line makes 2026 a clean test of how much pain at the pump actually changes behavior.
The bill for standing still is large, and it lands on households one tank at a time. Brown University's Climate Solutions Lab puts the extra national cost at $88 billion against a no-war baseline, and the Energy Policy Research Foundation estimates households spent between $300 and $730 more on gasoline from March through August than they did in the same months last year. That range is a car repair, a month of groceries or a credit card balance carried into the holidays, depending on the household absorbing it.
Lucas Davis, an energy economist at the University of California, Berkeley, laid out the federal numbers in a November 16 post for the Energy Institute at Haas, and his figures give the flat line its price tag. Regular gasoline has averaged $4.10 a gallon since March 1, against $2.94 in the week before the war began on February 28, and diesel has averaged $5.51 against $3.81 before the war. Prices ran 31 percent above the same period last year for gasoline and 51 percent higher for diesel, and Davis found no discernible evidence of a decline in consumption for either fuel.
His reading rests on the Energy Information Administration's product supplied figure, which counts gasoline leaving refineries and bulk terminals and serves as the federal proxy for demand. Davis is plain about the limit of that yardstick, since it measures fuel leaving the supply chain rather than fuel burned in engines. Transportation Department mileage data would settle the question directly, and it arrives with a lag. Its latest figures show no drop-off either, which leaves two independent measures pointing the same way.
For businesses
Amazon Business is Amazon’s purchasing store for companies, with business accounts and quantity ordering.Register with Amazon BusinessSurvey answers tell a different story from the fuel data, and the gap between them is wide enough to matter for anyone reading polls this year. An April Washington Post and ABC News survey found 44 percent of respondents saying they had cut back on driving, and a June Gallup poll put the share saying high prices were causing them to drive less at 57 percent. The tanks say otherwise. People reported a change in behavior that the national fuel ledger does not record.
Most driving is not discretionary in the short run, because the job, the school run and the grocery trip sit at fixed addresses that a household cannot renegotiate by Friday. A family absorbs the higher fuel bill long before it can move house, change jobs or replace a car, and the economics literature Davis cites has found the same pattern for decades. He calls the episode a useful reminder of the difference between what people report and what they do, and this year the reminder arrived with a bill attached.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.