Base PlayStation 5 Drops Frames In GTA VI
Grand Theft Auto VI holds a 99 on Metacritic from about 150 critic reviews, and Digital Foundry's launch testing tells a second story underneath the score. The base PlayStation 5 falls to 23 frames per second in heavy action while the PlayStation 5 Pro holds its 30-frame target.
Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague
Player scores open about 36 hours after release, and Rockstar has published no patch notes yet.
Digital Foundry clocked Grand Theft Auto VI at 23 frames per second on a base PlayStation 5 during a grenade-launcher rampage. The testers describe that scene as the worst case they found, with the average closer to the game's 30-frame target, and the frame rate stayed below 30 until the player left the area or died. A hard fight on the base console runs soft for as long as the fight lasts.
The stronger console in the same test program barely moved, because on PlayStation 5 Pro, Digital Foundry reports a near-flawless 30 frames per second across more than 50 hours of play. The Pro showed no dip in normal play and a worst case of 24 frames per second in an explosion-heavy scenario, and Rockstar locked every console version at 30 frames per second. The target is a ceiling on both machines, and the base console is the one that misses its own ceiling when the screen fills up.
The arithmetic explains why a seven-frame dip is easy to feel, since a 30-frame target puts a new frame on screen every 33.3 milliseconds. At 23 frames that gap stretches to about 43.5 milliseconds, and frames that arrive 8 to 10 milliseconds late in uneven gaps read as judder. The uneven spacing is the problem, even when the average rate sounds close to the target, and Digital Foundry reported before launch that the game was likely designed around 30 frames because of the size of its open-world simulation.
None of that performance detail sits inside the number most buyers saw first, because the review embargo lifted at 6 a.m. Eastern on Wednesday, November 18. Metacritic settled at 99 from roughly 150 critic reviews for PlayStation 5, and the score ties the record held since 1998 by The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, which earned its 99 from 22 reviews. OpenCritic also shows 99, from 81 reviews, and the lowest score visible on Metacritic's PlayStation 5 page is an 80 from ScreenHub, against perfect 100s from outlets including Game Informer and IGN France. The Xbox page carries only nine reviews, also at 99, so the verdict is overwhelmingly a PlayStation 5 verdict.
Critics praised the parts of the game a frame counter cannot grade, starting with the scale of the Leonida map. Reviewers also single out the weather systems, the enterable buildings, and the writing around Jason Duval and Lucia Caminos. Metacritic builds its score as a weighted average of critic reviews and has never published the weights, and the score reflects the reviews as published, so a later patch that steadies the base console would not move the 99 by itself.
Players found the dips on their own consoles within hours of the unlock, and PeakMetrics counted the reaction as it spread. The analytics firm tracked launch conversation across social platforms from November 11 through launch day and counted talk about frame drops and stutter at about 55 times the level of a typical pre-launch day. Among launch-day posts that took a side, 54.5 percent were favorable and 45.5 percent were unfavorable, and PeakMetrics says most of the criticism it sorted was about performance rather than the game itself. The launch-night outage on PlayStation Network was a separate problem on Sony's side, and TML covered that incident in its launch-day feature.
Two clocks now run on the performance question, and the first belongs to the players. Metacritic holds user scores for 36 hours after release, so the first player scores arrive about a day and a half after the unlock, well after the critics' verdict, and Rockstar has published no patch notes for either launch update. Version 01.002.000 landed on November 13 and version 01.002.001 followed on November 16, so players cannot yet read what the studio has already changed. A buyer on a base PlayStation 5 gets the same Leonida and the same story as everyone else, and the open question is how steady the studio can make the console's hardest scenes.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.