Genocide Judgment Leaves Compensation To A Phase Without Dates
The judgment against Myanmar is final, and its compensation order carries no amount and no payment date. The Court's own reparations record, from Uganda's five installments to a $378,890.59 environmental award it fixed itself, maps the phase that opens now, and the phase's first fixed date is Myanmar's report on November 19, 2028.
Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague
The compensation phase has no opening date, and the next fixed date in the case is Myanmar's report on restitution and compensation, due at the Court on November 19, 2028.
On September 1, Uganda paid the fifth and final installment of the largest reparations award the International Court of Justice has ever set.
The payment closed the money phase of the Congo's case against Uganda, which began with a liability judgment in December 2005 and a Court-set figure in February 2022. On Thursday, the same Court opened a money phase in a second case and left it unpriced, holding Myanmar responsible for genocide against the Rohingya and ordering compensation in an amount that a later phase will determine.
The operative orders require Myanmar to allow displaced Rohingya to return to their place of residence in safety, voluntarily, and with dignity, to reunite families separated by displacement inside Myanmar or abroad, and to compensate the Rohingya group and its members for the damage caused. The judgment sets no figure, no payment schedule, and no payment deadline. It gives Myanmar two years to send the Court a report describing the restitution measures it has adopted and stating its position on the amount and the modalities of compensation, and two years from Thursday runs out on November 19, 2028.
The Congo litigation shows how a blank of that size gets filled when the parties can't fill it. The Court held Uganda liable in 2005 and left the amount to negotiation, and the negotiations failed. The Congo asked the Court to decide in 2015, the Court took the question back, appointed independent experts, and on February 9, 2022, it awarded $325 million as a global sum: $225 million for damage to persons, $40 million for damage to property, and $60 million for damage related to natural resources. Judge Joan Donoghue, the Court's president at the time, said the award for damage to persons and property "reflects the harm suffered by individuals and communities as a result of Uganda's breach of its international obligations." The Court ordered five annual installments of $65 million, each due on September 1, with post-judgment interest at 6 percent on any installment paid late.
The method in that judgment is the part that transfers. The Congo's evidence couldn't establish a precise figure, and the Court said the destruction of evidence and the passage of time called for flexibility in the standard of proof. It assessed the damage within a range of possibilities and awarded global sums across broad categories rather than pricing each documented loss. Thursday's judgment against Myanmar found that Myanmar destroyed evidence on an extensive scale after the Court ordered its preservation in January 2020, including burned bodies and bulldozed clearance sites, so a compensation phase that follows the Congo template begins with the same evidentiary problem already decided against the respondent.
The Court has also priced a claim at the small end of the scale. Costa Rica and Nicaragua were given twelve months to agree on compensation for environmental damage from Nicaragua's canal digging on Costa Rican territory, and they didn't agree. On February 2, 2018, the Court fixed the total itself at $378,890.59, including $120,000 for the impairment of environmental goods and services, and it set the payment date in the same judgment. The two precedents bracket the Myanmar phase: a nine-figure global sum assembled by court-appointed experts over years, and a comparatively small accounting that the Court closed on its own in a single judgment.
Three questions about the Myanmar phase have no answer in the judgment. The Court hasn't said when the phase opens. It hasn't said whether it will appoint experts, as it did before pricing the Congo award. And it hasn't said what proof of loss it will accept from a displaced population whose villages the judgment found were bulldozed, cleared, and in places built over. A fourth question sits under all three: compensation is owed, in the judgment's words, to the Rohingya group and its members, and no mechanism in the judgment divides a future sum among the displaced.
Compensation is also only half of the reparation the Court ordered, and the other half has no pricing mechanism at all. Restitution in this judgment means physical return to northern Rakhine State and the reunification of separated families. UNHCR counted 1,189,213 Rohingya in the camps of Cox's Bazar and on Bhasan Char island in March 2026, and it identified 146,989 newly arrived Rohingya between January 2025 and March 2026 who had fled renewed violence in Rakhine State. In a camp in Bangladesh, Khin Maung, acting president of the United Council of Rohingya, spoke while the judgment was still being read in The Hague: "The Court has been addressing the right issues and acknowledging what we have been suffering for such a long time."
The judgment orders return to a place of residence, and it doesn't address the citizenship status that Myanmar has denied the Rohingya for decades, which is the legal ground any durable return has to stand on. Myanmar's military-backed government hadn't publicly responded to the judgment when the first day of reporting from The Hague closed. Britain moved on the day of the judgment itself: Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband announced the expulsion of Myanmar's defense attache and called urgently for a Security Council session, and the Council is the body a party can turn to when the other side refuses to perform a judgment, because the Court has no enforcement arm of its own.
The case now runs on the Court's calendar. Myanmar's report is due on November 19, 2028, and it's the next fixed date in the case. If the parties can't agree on compensation after that report, the Congo precedent describes the machinery that follows: experts, an assessment inside a range of possibilities, a global sum, and installments with interest on late payment. The Certain Activities precedent adds that the Court can fix the payment date itself. What neither precedent supplies is a return: in this judgment the larger half of the reparation is a displaced people's journey home, and that half carries no installment plan, no interest rate, and no date.
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.