$2 / month

Comment and reply across TML.

Start or manage membership

Most pulsed

Latest from other desks

tml.the modern leap
Food / Restaurants

Nadi Plates Opens Family Italian Restaurant On Farwell

Nadia Santaniello Bucholtz and her three children spent 19 months behind papered windows on Milwaukee's east side, renovating the room themselves, and the scratch-made Italian menu they built a food truck following on now has a dining room of its own.

TML Food DeskNov 20, 3:53 AM ET · 3 min read

Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague

Plates of tagliatelle and spaghetti vongole sit on a restaurant table in an archive photo. /wikimedia
Summary

A food truck that already works a major-league ballpark now has to prove the harder thing, that event crowds become weeknight regulars in a 40-seat room on Farwell Avenue.

Tap a passage. React to the part that matters.

Nadi Plates serves its first paying guests November 20 at 2163 North Farwell Avenue after 19 months behind papered windows. The restaurant is a family operation in the literal sense, because Nadia Santaniello Bucholtz leads it with her children Zach, Austin and Bianca, and the family started the business as a food truck and catering company in 2021. The truck built a trade most new restaurants would envy, working inside American Family Field and at Zócalo Food Park, and the catering side handles more than 50 weddings and events a year. The Farwell Avenue room, most recently home to Pomona Cider Co., is the first permanent dining room any of it has had.

The road to this address ran through a deal that died. The family announced a space inside the Crossroads Collective food hall in April 2025, then scrapped the plan in June 2026 and parted with New Land Enterprises on mutual terms, and the Farwell space was the tenth location offered to Nadia in nearly six years of looking. Once the family took it, they did the build-out themselves. Zach's account of the renovation is blunt. "To be our own contractors, our own architects, that was a challenge, but that's what makes it beautiful. It's 100% us." Austin describes the decision to finally uncover the windows after 19 months. "We made the decision a little while ago to uncover the windows because we're tired of people not knowing what's going on in here."

The room seats 40 to 45 across 2,100 square feet, with an open kitchen and one deliberate absence, since banquette seating is still weeks from finished and the family opened anyway. A photograph of Scott, Nadia's late husband and the children's father, sits on the bar. Nadia's stated standard for the space is domestic rather than theatrical. "We want it to feel like home," she said. Friends-and-family services ran November 19 through November 21, and Austin reported they had gone, in his word, dangerously smoothly. The public opening lands at 5 p.m. on November 20, with hours running Wednesday through Thursday and Sunday from 5 to 10 p.m. and Friday and Saturday from 5 to 11 p.m.

The menu prices like a neighborhood restaurant that knows its regulars' budgets. Starters run from broccolini and burrata at $10 and house focaccia at $11 to calamari at $15, and the pastas are the center of the card. Penne at $23, lasagna layered with béchamel at $25, rigatoni in vodka sauce and bucatini with peas and pancetta at $28 each. Chicken with prosciutto, spinach and ricotta costs $22, Parmesan-crusted salmon $32, and the filet mignon with gorgonzola tops the menu at $56. Ten-inch pizzas include a margherita at $17 and The Scotty at $18, named for the late patriarch and the first pie the truck ever sold. The Parmesan-crusted salmon has already emerged as the friends-and-family favorite. The bar pours classic cocktails and mostly Italian wines, Bianca is developing a mocktail list, and vegan and gluten-friendly dishes are built into the menu rather than handled as exceptions.

What Nadi Plates is testing is whether a catering reputation converts into a dining room. The truck's following is real but event-driven, and a 40-seat room on Farwell needs weeknight regulars rather than wedding clients. The family's next move is already sketched, with a daytime cafe called Il Grande Bambino planned for the space. For now the bet is narrower. A family that cooked for Milwaukee out of a truck for five years, renovated its own restaurant and put its father's photograph on the bar is asking the east side to come to dinner, and reservations are being taken online.

Sources

The conversation

A little more perspective.

Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.

The conversation.

Loading comments…

Keep your curiosity going.

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we might make a commission — it never changes what you pay. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.