Indiana Finally Brings Committee A Ranked Win
The Hoosiers are 9-1 after beating No. 18 USC on Saturday, and Tuesday night's third playoff rankings test whether the committee rewards the quality win it said Indiana lacked.
Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague
A No. 8 seed in Auerbach's bracket would put a first-round playoff game in Bloomington in December.
Curt Cignetti spent his bye week watching his team fall five spots without playing a snap. You can still hear the insult in Bloomington, because Indiana debuted at No. 4 in the first playoff rankings and then slid to No. 9 while sitting at home. The Hoosiers had not lost a game in between. They had simply waited, and the committee used the wait to reprice them in public.
Committee chair Hunter Yurachek explained the drop on television by pointing at Indiana's schedule and its lack of quality wins, and NBC's Nicole Auerbach noted that the Hoosiers' metrics also worsened as their former opponents kept losing. Read that ruling plainly and it was a homework assignment with a deadline. Go beat somebody ranked, then come back and argue.
Indiana walked into Saturday and beat No. 18 USC, which gives Cignetti's team a 9-1 record and the first ranked win the committee claimed to be waiting for. Cignetti has made no secret of how he feels about the people in that room, and now those people have to grade the exact result they demanded, with the third rankings arriving Tuesday night at 9 p.m. ET on ESPN.
ESPN's metrics make the case the room keeps dodging, because Indiana sits eighth in strength of record and its schedule ranks 39th, a full thirty spots ahead of UCLA's 69th. Auerbach projects the Hoosiers climbing one spot to No. 8, although she isn't sure the committee follows, since Tennessee won at Texas A&M and gave the room a fresher name to reward instead.
Her projected bracket carries the real money, because it seeds Indiana No. 8 and sends a first-round playoff game to Bloomington in December, with a home crowd, a full stadium, and a program that was an afterthought two years ago collecting a gate it has never collected. ESPN also gives Indiana a 78.2 percent chance of reaching the Big Ten title game, second only to UCLA, with Washington and Purdue left on the schedule.
Six rankings shows lead to Selection Sunday on December 6, and this third one is where the committee's story about Indiana either changes or hardens into a habit. The Hoosiers did the work in the order it was assigned. A flat number tonight tells every coach watching that the assignment was a moving target, and Cignetti will say so at the first microphone he finds.
Sources
The conversation.
Loading comments…
A little more perspective.
Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.