$2 / month

Comment and reply across TML.

Start or manage membership

Most pulsed

Latest from other desks

tml.the modern leap
News / Politics

Mullin Tells House Panel Outages Were No Attack

Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton and FBI Deputy Director Christopher Raia told the House Homeland Security Committee on Wednesday that the week's outages were separate technical failures with no attacker behind them. Mullin's written testimony still warned that Iranian cyber actors have targeted American infrastructure since February, and Democrats pressed him on his flight to a football game, deep cuts at the government's cyber agency and dozens of oversight letters his department has not answered.

TML News DeskNov 18, 4:08 PM ET · 7 min read

Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague

Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin testifies before the House Homeland Security Committee at the Cannon House Office Building in Washington, D.C. (archive). Photo: Tia Dufour, U.S. Department of Homeland Security (public domain), via Wikimedia Commons.
Summary

The industry phone call Mullin described has no announced date, CISA's current fully onboarded headcount never entered the record, and 15 of the 36 oversight letters in Thompson's count remain unanswered by the secretary's own tally.

Tap a passage. React to the part that matters.

Bennie Thompson opened the hearing holding posters that quoted the secretary's own words back at him, and the room stayed adversarial from there.

The posters went up at the start of the committee's annual worldwide threats hearing, titled "Worldwide Threats to the Homeland: 25 Years After 9/11," which convened at 10 a.m. on Wednesday, November 18, in Room 310 of the Cannon House Office Building. Mullin sat at the witness table with Clayton and Raia, and questioning from both parties kept returning to the failures that had spent a week on front pages: the Microsoft outage on Thursday, November 12, the nationwide flight ground stop on Friday, the banking disruption on Monday and the outage on the National Security Agency's internal network.

Mullin told the committee that investigators had found nothing connecting those incidents to each other. "We have seen nothing that would indicate that they are related," he said, and he told members the department had reached out to the companies involved while CISA, its cyber agency, watched for online traffic pointing to a shared cause and saw none. He put his certainty in a number. "We're 98% confident that there is no nefarious activity going on," Mullin said. Asked whether he had ever seen so many outages land inside so short a stretch, he answered that he had "absolutely not."

Clayton attached the intelligence community's confidence level to the same conclusion. Each outage had a different root cause, he said, and analysts had checked the failures against the techniques, tactics and procedures seen in past hacking campaigns. "Do we see any of them here?" Clayton said. "We do not see them." His summary was categorical. "These are separate service outages associated with maintenance and technical changes," he said. "They are not a coordinated or state-sponsored attack." Raia said FBI cybersecurity experts had reviewed the outages since the incidents first emerged, and he matched Clayton's wording: "At this point, there is no indication whatsoever that there is any cyber malicious activity related to any of those incidents."

The largest of the failures, Friday's ground stop, halted flights across the country for about four hours while the FAA's contractor, L3Harris, replaced aging copper communications lines with fiber-optic connections at a remote facility, and about 18,000 flights were canceled in the disruption that followed. The NSA outage, which forced employees to stagger their arrivals at work, grew out of patching for vulnerabilities in PHP, the widely used web software, as Clayton described it publicly on Tuesday.

Mullin offered the committee one concrete step his department is taking in response. He said DHS was "convening a phone call with industry" to go over the failures with the companies involved, and he gave members no date for the call and no list of who would join it. At another point in the hearing, he turned to Clayton and asked the intelligence chief to lay out what investigators had established so far.

The reassurance arrived alongside a warning that now sits in the hearing record in writing. In the testimony Mullin submitted to the committee, he wrote that "Iranian government cyber actors and pro-Iran cybercriminals have targeted US critical infrastructure networks since the conflict with Iran began earlier this year." The statement names transportation, health care, water, energy and financial services as targets, says the operations have historically produced "localized and minimally disruptive effects" against inadequately secured industrial control systems, and warns that the same openings could produce more serious consequences. His written testimony also says Customs and Border Protection detected more than 30,000 suspicious drone flights along the Southwest border in 2026.

Questioning about Iran turned to reports of plots inside the United States, including a reported plot to detonate a dirty bomb in Washington that officials have not said Iran can carry out or intends to. Clayton said Iran works from "a suite of threats" focused on mass casualties of civilians, and that the threats "have been around for a long time." The United States faces a "heightened threat from the Iranians," he said, and he described Iran's network capability as "very sophisticated, global, and one that we need to combat seriously and with all the tools we have available." Mullin told the committee Iran has targeted American infrastructure with cyberattacks since the war began, and he kept that record separate from the outages, which he said Tehran did not cause.

Thompson's posters grew out of a longer fight over oversight, and the exchange over them produced the hearing's first hard numbers. Thompson, the committee's ranking Democrat, said the department had ignored dozens of the committee's letters. Mullin answered with his own count: in the 61 days the House has been in session, Thompson's office sent him 36 letters, and the department answered 21 of them. "I did reach out to you in good faith, wanted to have a good conversation with you, and in 15 seconds, unfortunately, you came after me," Mullin said. He called the posters "completely inaccurate," and he said a quote printed on one of them referred to how quickly the government reopened the airspace after the ground stop.

The sharpest criticism of Mullin was personal, and it concerned Saturday. The day after the ground stop, Mullin flew on a government plane to Baton Rouge for the LSU game against Texas, and Democrats treated the trip as the defining image of the week. Mullin said the trip had been planned well ahead of time, that he took his niece to her first LSU game, and that the airspace had been open for nearly 24 hours when he flew. Canceling while the airspace stood completely open "could bring confusion," he argued. "That would show distrust that we're not even willing to fly," he said. He said he reimbursed the government for the flight, and that his job requires him to travel on a government aircraft.

Rep. James Walkinshaw of Virginia questioned Mullin standing in front of a chart titled "Trump Admin Slashes CISA Workforce." The chart showed the cyber agency's personnel falling from 3,387 to about 2,200 since January 2025 while counted cyberattacks climbed, and Walkinshaw asked whether pushing out more than 1,000 employees had been a mistake. Mullin said he was not in the job when that decision was made and did not know the reasoning behind it. Asked how many fully onboarded employees CISA has today, he could not give the committee the number, and he could not say whether any of the agency's recent hires were people it had pushed out. "I said we're hiring new people," Mullin said. "We need to bring experts in." Walkinshaw pressed the point: "You have no information about CISA's workforce when you come before this committee today as the cyber threat facing the American people is exploding?"

One seat at the witness table drew attention for who was not in it. Chairman Andrew Garbarino, a Republican, opened the hearing by criticizing FBI Director Kash Patel for declining to appear. "I am disappointed that Director Patel chose not to appear before the committee today," Garbarino said. He called the refusal a "significant departure from well-established committee precedent," and he noted the committee had given Patel the date in August. Thompson used his time with Raia, Patel's stand-in, to ask a direct question: "Are you aware of any instance where the president has directed the FBI to investigate or not investigate anyone?" Raia answered, "Absolutely not."

Mullin declined to discuss the status of investigations into the deaths of Renee Good and Alex Pretti, both shot by federal immigration officers, telling Rep. Pablo José Hernández, "I cannot talk about ongoing investigations." Hernández answered him in open session: "Does that justify the killing? And why do you have to bring up that comparison? That is very disrespectful to those people." Rep. Al Green of Texas told Mullin he ought to be arrested over the Pretti case, and Mullin replied, "Hope you enjoy your forced retirement." On a separate line of questions, Mullin said the decision by his predecessor, former Secretary Kristi Noem, to cut training for new immigration officers predated him, that the previous training standards have been restored, and that officers who have not completed training "have been put on administrative leave until that happens."

The committee adjourned with three items Mullin described still unscheduled or uncounted. The industry phone call has no announced date, CISA's current fully onboarded headcount never entered the record, and 15 of the 36 letters in Thompson's count remain unanswered by the secretary's own tally.

Sources

The conversation

A little more perspective.

Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.

The conversation.

Loading comments…

Keep your curiosity going.

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we might make a commission — it never changes what you pay. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.