$2 / month

Comment and reply across TML.

Start or manage membership

Most pulsed

Latest from other desks

tml.the modern leap
Style / Fashion

Rental Startups Rewrite The Closet Without Subscriptions

A new class of clothing rental companies has dropped the subscription model that defined the category. Hauteline, Pickle, Louvelle, and Isle of Monday rent by the piece, while Nuuly grows inside Urban Outfitters and Rent the Runway shrinks, Fashionista reported on November 17.

TML Style DeskNov 19, 9:04 AM ET · 3 min read

Edited and fact-checked by Stephen Sprague

A shopper browsing a crowded clothing rack (archive). The newest rental companies let customers borrow single pieces from stores, strangers' closets, and vintage archives. Photo: PattayaPatrol, via Wikimedia Commons.
Summary

The piece-by-piece closets now test whether trust scores can do the work a warehouse used to do.

Tap a passage. React to the part that matters.

The newest clothing rental companies rent by the piece, and their closets live in other people's homes. The subscription model defined rental for a decade, and the numbers now point in two directions at once, because Nuuly reported the stronger quarter. The rental service inside URBN posted a 28.6 percent increase in net sales to $179 million in its most recent quarter. A 30.4 percent increase in active subscribers drove that growth, while Rent the Runway reported the opposite direction. The company that made rental famous posted a 3.8 percent decline in active subscribers and an accumulated deficit of $1.1 billion in its recent second quarter results.

Four startups are building the next version of the category, and none of them uses a subscription, since Hauteline rents piece by piece. Pickle, Louvelle, and Isle of Monday work the same way, so a customer borrows one dress for one weekend. She owes nothing the month after, and the structure gives shoppers room to borrow, lend, and in some cases buy the piece outright. Fashionista profiled the four companies on November 17, as rental benefits from shoppers who lack storage space. Shoppers who watch clothing prices closely are driving the same shift.

Hauteline runs the most traditional store of the four, and its founders stock it like editors, since Kristie Chow and Michelle Li built the company around indie labels. The New York rental-retail hybrid sources full size ranges directly from smaller brands, and a Collina Strada belt rents for $12 a day. A Grace Gui black-tie dress rents for $33 a day, across rental periods of four, eight, 16, or 30 days, and most pieces are also for sale. A renter who buys one pays only the difference between the retail price and the rent already paid, and Chow explained the customer in one line. "Our generation grew up thrifting and on Depop, and doesn't care if something's been worn before," Chow told Fashionista.

The company's physical bet sits on Orchard Street in the Lower East Side, where a flagship store lets customers try pieces on before renting, and Li explained why the store exists. Shoppers kept saying women's sizing is difficult to judge online, so the founders gave them a fitting room, and the rental data from the floor now guides which brands the company stocks. That loop is a store teaching an app what to carry. It runs opposite to the warehouse model the first rental generation built.

Pickle scales the same idea across strangers' closets instead of a warehouse, because Julia O'Mara and Brian McMahon built it as a peer-to-peer platform. Pickle lists more than 600,000 items across 2,000 brands nationwide, and members lend pieces from their own closets for a day to four weeks. On the platform, 67 percent of Pickle's sellers also rent, and a Norma Kamali fringe dress in its Suede Season list rents for $95. That price sits against a $264 retail price, and O'Mara credits the network effect in plain terms. "When you have that built-in network of friends, trust compounds as more people hear about Pickle from a trusted source," O'Mara said. Pickle keeps a flagship in the West Village and a pop-up in Wynwood, Miami.

Louvelle and Isle of Monday push the model toward the high end and the archive, starting with an invitation-only door at Louvelle. The platform verifies member identities and gives each member a trust score that sets how much they can rent at once. That system is built for pieces like a $5,000 Bulgari clutch, and Isle of Monday rents vintage designer pieces from the other end of the timeline. It opened in May with 150 products and grew out of a beta site that drew a 30,000-person waitlist in late 2025, and its founders run an appointment-only showroom in New York. The shared lesson across all four is a design one, because the hard part of rental was never the dress. It was always the trust, the sizing, and the return trip, so the new companies spend their effort there instead of on a monthly fee.

Sources

The conversation

A little more perspective.

Reading is free. Verified members can comment and reply for $2 a month.

The conversation.

Loading comments…

Keep your curiosity going.

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we might make a commission — it never changes what you pay. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.